Lessons from Noriega’s Fall for Trump’s Venezuela Strategy
Noriega lessons for Venezuela are back in the conversation as Washington debates how hard to lean on Nicolás Maduro. The swift U.S. removal of Manuel Noriega in 1989 tempts policymakers to believe decisive power can end a crisis cleanly. It didn’t then, and it won’t now without a durable plan. If a future Trump-led approach turns more coercive, the most useful Noriega lessons for Venezuela are about everything that happens after the first headline—legitimacy, institutions, civilian harm, regional buy-in, and the hard slog of recovery.
What Operation Just Cause actually achieved—and what it didn’t
Operation Just Cause toppled Panama’s strongman in days, captured him, and restored the elected government. It was a tightly planned, overwhelming show of force that met its primary military objectives. But the operation also produced civilian casualties, infrastructure disruption, and a long tail of governance challenges. Even authoritative summaries concede wide-ranging casualty estimates and a complicated reconstruction phase that followed the photo-op moment. Encyclopedia Britannica+2Wikipedia+2
Those facts matter for Noriega lessons for Venezuela because they puncture the myth of “quick and clean.” In Panama, the U.S. had geography, local force imbalance, and relatively simple political factions on its side. Caracas is a bigger, denser urban battlespace. Venezuela’s security services are fragmented, politicized, and tied into illicit revenue streams. Any street-to-street fight would be bloodier, and any post-conflict stabilization would be tougher. The most sobering Noriega lessons for Venezuela are that shock action is the easy part; stabilizing a traumatized state is the bill that comes due.
Why Venezuela is not Panama
The differences are structural. Venezuela’s crisis layers state collapse onto mass displacement, organized crime, and sanctions-battered oil economics. More than 7.7 million Venezuelans have fled; the regional spillover strains Colombia, Brazil, and beyond. A rapid raid cannot reverse that diaspora or rebuild ruined institutions. Noriega lessons for Venezuela therefore begin with humility: toppling a ruler is not the same as repairing a nation. UN Refugees+1
The regime’s external lifelines compound the problem. Caracas has cultivated support—diplomatic, financial, and technical—from Russia, China, Iran, Cuba, and Turkey across the last decade. In 2025, Moscow and Caracas signed a broad energy and strategic partnership; Russian officials continue to criticize U.S. military moves in the Caribbean. Beijing remains a critical destination for Venezuelan oil. These ties mean any heavy-handed U.S. move would echo globally. That’s a central Noriega lessons for Venezuela point: wider power politics now run through Caracas in a way they did not through Panama City in 1989. CSIS+3Reuters+3Reuters+3
The escalation ladder is crowded—and slippery
Another complication is the Caribbean theater’s crowded escalation ladder. Analyses have tracked increased U.S. force posture, logistics staging, and interdiction operations around the region, while Maduro courts outside security help. In an environment where multiple militaries and proxies overlap, miscalculation is easy, and faits accomplis are risky. If a Trump policy leans on coercive signaling, Noriega lessons for Venezuela suggest clarity of objectives and limits from day one, or signals will be misread and crises will outrun control. CSIS+2The Washington Post+2
What actually transfers from Panama to Venezuela
The first transferable Noriega lessons for Venezuela are negative—what not to assume.
First, do not assume regime collapse upon first strike. The Maduro government has endured sanctions, attempted uprisings, and diplomatic isolation. Its survival toolkit—patronage, repression, outside partners—makes it resilient to shocks. Second, do not assume a friendly, coherent post-intervention authority is waiting in the wings. The Venezuelan opposition is courageous but fragmented; the state is hollowed out; criminal networks run parallel economies. Third, do not assume the region will accept a U.S.-designed solution. Legitimacy in Latin America runs through multilateral process, not unilateral muscle. Those are unglamorous Noriega lessons for Venezuela, but they are the ones that prevent quagmires.
The positive lessons are more demanding. If Washington wants durable change, it must sequence pressure, diplomacy, and relief so that Venezuelans—not outsiders—own the endgame. That means fusing sanctions relief to verified political steps, surrounding negotiations with real enforcement for spoilers, and scaling humanitarian channels that bypass regime theft. It also means putting civil-police reform, judiciary repair, and oil-sector cleanup on the table early, not as afterthoughts. In plain terms, Noriega lessons for Venezuela argue for a peace-building mindset, not just a crisis-management mindset.
If force is on the table, discipline matters more than bravado
A future Trump team might argue that credible force creates leverage. Perhaps—but only if it is wrapped in disciplined constraints. The most practical Noriega lessons for Venezuela here are operational and political: tighten rules of engagement to minimize civilian harm; define a narrow military objective linked to a realistic political settlement; pre-build regional cover through the OAS and key neighbors; and publish an after-action clock that shifts from kinetic tasks to institution-building within weeks, not months. Those are not abstract ideals. They are the difference between a tactical win and strategic drift, as the Panama record itself makes clear. Encyclopedia Britannica+1
The multilateral frame is not cosmetic—it is the strategy
Regional coalitions and UN mechanisms are not window dressing. They are the only way to convert pressure into legitimacy and legitimacy into compliance. Noriega lessons for Venezuela therefore prioritize a coalition approach that binds Colombia, Brazil, and the Caribbean Community to any pathway forward, whether that is renewed negotiations or a calibrated pressure campaign. Given the cross-border refugee flow, host countries have real equities; folding their needs into the plan makes compliance likelier and backsliding costlier. UN Refugees
What “success” would need to look like
Success would be measured not in a televised surrender but in quieter metrics: credible elections that all major factions accept; a phased security-sector reform that disarms irregulars; a judiciary that can prosecute oil-sector graft; and a humanitarian pipeline that shrinks the refugee outflow. Those are the boring, essential Noriega lessons for Venezuela—build institutions, or you will build new crises.
The risks that never go away
Even with a coalition, the risks are stubborn. Urban combat would be devastating. Economic stabilization would need years of oil-sector and currency repair. External spoilers could arm militias or jam maritime lanes. And any perception of U.S. overreach would entrench anti-American narratives for a generation. The harshest Noriega lessons for Venezuela are that force multiplies both power and responsibility. You inherit what you break.
Bottom line
Noriega lessons for Venezuela are not about emulating a lightning raid; they are about respecting the gravity of state repair. If a Trump strategy tilts toward hard power, the plan has to start where Panama’s plan ended: legitimacy, institutions, and regional ownership. Otherwise, the U.S. risks “winning” the first week and losing the decade. The smartest reading of Noriega lessons for Venezuela points to a disciplined mix of pressure and diplomacy, scaled humanitarian access, and a negotiated pathway that Venezuelans can actually carry. Anything else is theater, not strategy. CSIS+1
Further Reading
Britannica: “United States invasion of Panama (Operation Just Cause)” — overview, objectives, and casualty debates. Encyclopedia Britannica
U.S. Army (official history page): “Operation Just Cause: the Invasion of Panama, December 1989.” army.mil
UNHCR Venezuela Situation — current displacement figures and humanitarian planning. UNHCR+1
CSIS: “Escalation Against the Maduro Regime in Venezuela” — force posture and regional dynamics. CSIS
Reuters: “Putin and Venezuela’s Maduro sign strategic partnership agreement in Moscow.” Reuters
Reuters: “Russia denounces ‘excessive’ U.S. military force in Caribbean, backs Venezuela.” Reuters
UN Refugee USA (UNHCR USA): Venezuela Crisis explainer and statistics. UN Refugees
CSIS: “Miscalculation and Escalation over the Essequibo.” CSIS
EBSCO Research Starters: “Noriega capture and trial” — legal aftermath and context.
Connect with the Author
Curious about the inspiration behind The Unmaking of America or want to follow the latest news and insights from J.T. Mercer? Dive deeper and stay connected through the links below—then explore Vera2 for sharp, timely reporting.
About the Author
Discover more about J.T. Mercer’s background, writing journey, and the real-world events that inspired The Unmaking of America. Learn what drives the storytelling and how this trilogy came to life.
[Learn more about J.T. Mercer]
NRP Dispatch Blog
Stay informed with the NRP Dispatch blog, where you’ll find author updates, behind-the-scenes commentary, and thought-provoking articles on current events, democracy, and the writing process.
[Read the NRP Dispatch]
Vera2 — News & Analysis
Looking for the latest reporting, explainers, and investigative pieces? Visit Vera2, North River Publications’ news and analysis hub. Vera2 covers politics, civil society, global affairs, courts, technology, and more—curated with context and built for readers who want clarity over noise.
[Explore Vera2]
Whether you’re interested in the creative process, want to engage with fellow readers, or simply want the latest updates, these resources are the best way to stay in touch with the world of The Unmaking of America—and with the broader news ecosystem at Vera2.
Free Chapter
Begin reading The Unmaking of America today and experience a story that asks: What remains when the rules are gone, and who will stand up when it matters most? Join the Fall of America mailing list below to receive the first chapter of The Unmaking of America for free and stay connected for updates, bonus material, and author news.
