GPT-5 Backlash: Why We Always Hate New AI Models

The GPT-5 backlash didn’t take weeks or even days to arrive. It was practically instantaneous. Less than twenty-four hours after the model went live, Reddit was flooded with posts demanding the return of GPT-4. Twitter (or X, if you insist) lit up with complaints that GPT-5 “feels off.” Screenshots and side-by-side comparisons were everywhere.

It got loud enough that Sam Altman himself said GPT-4 access would be restored alongside GPT-5. That’s not nothing.

If you’ve been around for previous releases, this all feels very familiar. We’ve seen this movie before—and we’ll see it again.

The Predictable Cycle of AI Change

Every time OpenAI releases a new model, the cycle plays out almost exactly the same:

A new version launches.
Early adopters rush to try it.
Social media fills with negative takes.
After a few weeks, the model goes from “unusable” to “essential.”

When GPT-4 dropped, I remember seeing post after post claiming GPT-3.5 was “way better.” People complained the new model was slower, dumber, more verbose. They picked apart every difference.

Fast forward a few months, and GPT-4 was the gold standard. The complaints had faded, replaced by guides, prompt libraries, and people bragging about what GPT-4 could do. The same folks who dismissed it at launch were suddenly defending it like it was their childhood dog.

Now the GPT-5 backlash is here, and it’s following the exact same script.

Why We React This Way

Humans don’t just dislike change—we’re wired to resist it, especially when it messes with something we use daily. The tools we rely on are extensions of our workflows, our habits, even our thinking. When a new model changes how those tools behave, our first instinct is to see it as a loss, not an improvement.

That’s exactly what’s happening with the GPT-5 backlash. People have spent over a year learning GPT-4’s quirks—how to prompt it, when to push it, when to reset the conversation. GPT-5 shows up with different rhythms and slightly altered behaviors, and suddenly all those learned habits are out the window.

My Own Frustrations

I’m not immune to this reaction either. My biggest gripe with GPT-5 so far? It has a tendency to ask for multiple clarifications before doing any actual work.

With GPT-4, I could say:

“Write me a blog post about X.”

And it would just… start writing.

With GPT-5, it goes more like this:

“Do you want it structured with headings? How long? Should I focus more on Y or Z?”

Sometimes that back-and-forth happens twice before anything gets produced. It’s like hiring a painter who spends the first two days showing you color swatches instead of picking up a brush.

The Tradeoff

Here’s the thing, though—the writing is better. Noticeably better.

Less of what I call “AI smell.” No more constant list-of-three sentence patterns. Fewer unnecessary em-dashes. It feels more natural, more like human writing.

Show, Don’t Tell: GPT-4 vs GPT-5

I asked both models to describe a rainy street at night.

GPT-4:

The rain poured down in sheets, soaking the pavement, drenching the streetlights, and making the night shimmer. Cars splashed through puddles, headlights reflecting in countless streams, creating an atmosphere both lonely, wistful, and oddly serene.

GPT-5:

Rain slicked the pavement and blurred the glow of the streetlights. Headlights cut through the haze, and every puddle rippled with the passing of a car. The night felt quiet, but not still.

The GPT-5 version is leaner, tighter, and more grounded. It doesn’t feel like it’s auditioning for a high school poetry contest. It gets the scene across without drowning it in adjectives.

That’s not just a subjective “feeling.” For writers, marketers, or anyone using AI for public-facing content, cleaner writing is a direct upgrade.

Why the GPT-5 Backlash Feels So Loud

The GPT-5 backlash feels louder than usual partly because we’re in a different AI moment than when GPT-4 launched. Back then, most people were still experimenting. Today, millions are using AI tools in their daily work—content creation, coding, marketing, research, customer support. Any disruption to a workflow now feels personal.

Add to that the social media echo chamber, and every negative take gets amplified. If your first few prompts with GPT-5 feel slower or clunkier than GPT-4, you can instantly find hundreds of people online who agree with you, screenshot in hand.

Adaptation Happens Fast

Here’s the thing: this phase doesn’t last. Within a few weeks, people will have adapted. They’ll discover GPT-5’s strengths, learn to work around its quirks, and start producing better work with it.

By then, the loudest voices in the GPT-5 backlash will have quieted down—or shifted to bragging about what they can do with the “new” model. And when GPT-6 eventually rolls out, we’ll start the whole cycle over again.

Looking Ahead

I’m not here to say GPT-5 is flawless. It’s not. The clarifying prompt loop is slowing me down, and the difference in “feel” between versions takes some getting used to.

But I also know this: the same thing happened when GPT-4 launched, and it will happen again with GPT-6. People hate change, then adapt to it, then defend it fiercely until the next change arrives.

The GPT-5 backlash is just the latest reminder that every leap forward in AI comes wrapped in a little discomfort. Progress rarely feels comfortable in the moment—but it’s hard to deny the upgrades once you’ve lived with them.

Connect with the Author

Curious about the inspiration behind The Unmaking of America or want to follow the latest news and insights from J.T. Mercer? Dive deeper and stay connected through the links below:

About the Author
Discover more about J.T. Mercer’s background, writing journey, and the real-world events that inspired The Unmaking of America. Learn what drives the storytelling and how this trilogy came to life.
NRP Dispatch Blog
Stay informed with the NRP Dispatch blog, where you’ll find author updates, behind-the-scenes commentary, and thought-provoking articles on current events, democracy, and the writing process.

Whether you’re interested in the creative process, want to engage with fellow readers, or simply want the latest updates, these resources are the best way to stay in touch with the world of The Unmaking of America and beyond.

Free Chapter

Begin reading The Unmaking of America today and experience a story that asks: What remains when the rules are gone, and who will stand up when it matters most? Join the Fall of America mailing list below to receive the first chapter of The Unmaking of America for free and stay connected for updates, bonus material, and author news.

Read the first chapter free

AI, Author Notes, Reader Resources

The GPT-5 Backlash Was Inevitable